Wednesday, July 1, 2009
Free Maine reporters. Delegate flash stories to Licenced Practical bloggers. Use saved$ to finance IR
With consequently dwindled or actually non-existent time allotted or budgeted for them by the station operators to spend the several weeks or more of time and effort chewing through the multiferous layers of investigation into any of the myriad thorns presently in the side of the Maine Body Politic. One brought to attention recently - inmate exile - would take weeks of reading through masses of documents hand written, typed, electronic, of conducting dozen or more of interviews calls meetings. But the results would be well worth it.
Solution: Let the media outlets farm out routine (yet vital by its very routineness) documentary coverage to Licensed Practical Bloggers or LPBs - Some percentage of the documentary coverage of the myriad of governmental and nongovernmental meetings, speeches carnivals festivals, coverage of automotive mayhem and other committee meeting coverage would be done by them.
LPB's "Licenced Practical Bloggers"? Some standard would be set and enforced by local news directors. As micro contributors, they're getting less per word; the saved money then applied toward enabling the investigative arts. Professional journalists would still keep their hands in as many of the documentary type events coverage as they pleased (so long as their investigative efforts don't suffer.)
But overall let the minutiae be covered by the micromedia, who are well positioned for it, and set our professional journalists loose on bringing to light the reasons behind the vital issues of the day, ever shifting as they are. That is a hit or miss business; all the more reason to allow greater chunks of the budget for Maine journalists to pursue their necessary arts of deliberative investigative journalism.
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
MPBN, Village Soup, other Maine media shrug and turn aside as Baldacci affirms his pro-torture position re Mainer inmates
So does Maine media look into why these eight Mainers dared to put their necks on the line?
Of course not! (with a few tiny exceptions). Take Herald Gazette/Village Soup reporter Shlomit Auciello. Please!
Primed to the gills with info about the raisons d'etre for the Maine state prison's present and past hunger strikes, about Maine's history of retribution against those inmates daring to lawfully rock the boat about the devastating effect that prolonged sensory deprivation has on the minds and hearts of those being held in such circumstances, primed with all this info what does Shlomit Auciello do?
Why, she builds her story around the exhalations of the Great Bloviator: Associate Corrections Commissioner for Public Relations Denise Lord. Right from the start:
"According to DOC Associate Commissioner Denise Lord...."
Lord is good at her job. Like one of Saddam's officials, or a guantanamo public affairs officer he can extoll the positive side of torture: it is "an incentive to inmates " Auciello dutifully reports this party line.
"They have access to reading materials and magazines," Lord observed, leaving out the well known observation that anyone held in sensory deprivation units quickly becomes disoriented and unable to read as the days and weeks pass.
Most disgraceful perhaps. Auciello tries to sugarcoat the disgusting fact that at any given moment, the state of Maine continually puts men and women in and out of sensory deprivation tanks for widely varying lengths of time. Letting Lord get away with spinning it polyannaishly as "fewer than 2.5 percent of the prison's 2,200 inmates!" as though sensory deprivation was not a practice that can only be described as intentional infliction of torture, carried out in the name of the People of Maine.
But that wasnt the story Lord wanted, and Auciello like the rest of the callow media went right along with the associate commish.
So, policies that so conflict with international human rights treaties that global sanctions against te Baldacci Administration ought to be imposed? Not an issue.
beyond the beachhead that the hunger strikers have established in their brief campaign. They are doubtless learning the punitive consequences of their courage, which we should not allow to have happened in vain.
Downeast Mag - part 2 of Jeff Clark pimps for MDOT re Sears Island .
Last week's entry noted the bizarre juxtaposition of "veteran journalist" Jeff Clark, with an article about Sears Island bearing his byline that is so saccharine, so one-sided, so distant from the truth, so determinedly ignorant of the impacts such a port would have on Penobscot Bay's fishery and tourism industries, that one could only assume that when Jeff found out he was getting the boot from Downeast Magazine, he decided that in harsh economic times the best employer would be Uncle Baldacci.
Hence the hymn-like quality of Clark's paean to the Great Governor. For in centuries past, the Lords of Power would indeed occasionally reward such inspired syncophancy with a meaningless but well paying slot in the royal administration.
Why not me? must have occured to the unemployed scribbler. Surely a veteran with chops like me can pen an ode to the governor that will lift me out of this squalid scramble for column inches that the new Downeast demands I enter into.
But to do that, the old Clark, the one who formerly "...did the tough stories" as one admirer said, who formerly "captured issues' complexities in a way that readers could understand, but without condescension..."
had to vanish.
NeoJeff went casting about for something to pangyricize about. His eye must have fallen upon a Maine Coast Heritage Trust media release praising itself for snatching away 600 acres of Sears Island from the public and condemning the rest, including the bay's more important groundfish nursery to degradation and outright destruction.
The rest is history - at least a flawed, cracked, mirror image of history, which conveniently leaves out every thing that would counter Downeast's Maine-as-funhouse carnival spin. Shall we count the ways?
* The headline: "How Sears Island was Saved". Even Clark at his grovliest wouldn't have stooped THAT low, so we shall assume a copyeditor spat it out in a moment of cynicism that caught the publisher's eye. Saved indeed.
* "For decades the largest undeveloped island on the U.S. eastern seaboard has been a source of controversy." Ah Jeff.... T'was not the island that was a source of controversy, it was the various industrial schemes that tried to squat upon her wild face. Wassumkeag - pronounced like "blossom keg" - was not controversial to the people of Searsport and the surrounding region at all. Why should it be? It was absentee-owned land that allowed for light recreation. People married there. Had their ashes strewn there. Fished, hunted and hiked there.
Occasionally Big Money showed up and tried to industrialize it, but conservationists always rallied round the people of Searsport and the island, and the threat was thrown back. That was, until Angus King's doomed industrial sprawl attempt on the island's life left Wasumkeag sorely wounded and parts of the bay's ecosystem in disarray.
* "As one of the last remaining sites suitable for a deepwater port in Maine, business and government officials have long seen it as the key component of an industrial revival in the Penobscot Bay region."
The Penobscot Bay region keeps wondering just why it is that the "revival" schemes these do-gooder wannabes in Augusta keep hatching have everything to do with enriching big absentee industries, and little or nothing to do with enriching the extant thriving decentralized industries that have driven Penobscot Bay's economies for centuries.
Have in fact, everything to do with destroying several of the keystones of those economies that Downeast usually fawns over: the commercial fishing industry - though this is something Jeff Clark has but dimly heard of, for the volumes writ about the irreplaceability of the habitats that must be dredged away for this "key" port, is freely available - on the internet, at the agencies headquarters, indeed from the archives of quisling Maine Sierra Club - the federal and state memos and reports, the EIS, the SEIS, the maps, all of it is available.
The shining sands of Sears Island's nomenclature are as much those rich sandy shoals off her western shore, gleaming with phot0plankton phosphorescent in the summer night.
But Clark feigns ignorance of such detail; the vision he would spread across Downeast's pages must (and does) sing the praises of Wise John, so loudly that he must be hoping that the proposed darkening of Wasumkeag's shining sands is well nigh invisible under the radiance of Baldacci's gleaming visionary pate.
Time presses. We'll return to our discussion soon, but what Jeff Clark has done is held up the two bloody halves of the baby that Governor John has split apart and declared them to be tasteful and even, as in his article's coup de gras - one must make sure the nursery side of the island has ceased its annoying cries, - declared that what was best for big industry was best for Maine
To Be Continued
Friday, May 8, 2009
Former Downeast Mag writer pimps Baldacci/Damon port plan
A slapback against getting the Downeast boot, Clark's article (editorial? or...consider the publication: puff piece) is a lengthy paean to MDOT (and to Governor Baldacci and his understudy-who-would-be-governor Senator Dennis Damon,) as they gaily bent state law, mocked the Maine Constitution and trampled over hundreds of small businesses over the last three years in an effort to rush installation of a supersize container port onto 940 acre Sears Island - including dredging away the nursery shoals at the headwaters of Maine's most lobster-rich bay,) Clarks missive-by-any-name stands head and shoulders above the rest of the Sears Island fantasies spun by other dogs on other laps.
A marvel of, no, what must be a purposely grotesque parody of Downeast's shameless chamber of commerce huggerism, Clark manages through dint of great labor to carefully get every fact wrong, and to reach precisely the wrong conclusion.
This may seem puzzling in the light of pronouncements by his admirers, such as a recent one calling him "a reporter with real news sense and serious writing chops" , Indeed Jeff was considered the Voice of Downeast Maine
Ah but that was the old Jeff Clark. The new Jeff Clark, cast adrift from his Downeast mooring, would much rather, it appears, find a public affairs slot in a Damon administration. Government public relations - the only media field that grows as the economy contracts.
A versatile scribbler, he would be as much at home flacking the Department of Corrections as he would the Governor's office. While DOC's Asst Commissioner for PR Denise Lord would not willingly give up her slot spinning happy faces onto reports of institutional mayhem at the state prison, it may be that Dan Cashman at the Governor's office has tired of spinning his Nibs' doings and little machinations.
There, Clark's obsequiousness to the aforementioned politicos trying to force a container port and railyard onto Sears Island would pay off. Notably the way this "reporter with real news sense and serious writing chops" tried to conceal the fact that it was Governor Baldacci himself who almost sneaked a Liquid Natural Gas port and plant onto Sears Island during his first term;
saddest and worst, that Jeff Clark couldn't trouble himself to contact or even once directly mention any of the opponents of the island splitting plan; and in a hundred other ways, played fast and loose with the facts in that inimitable hazy opium dream style that this suddenly former Downeast Magazine writer Jeff Clark perfected.
To be continued.
Monday, May 4, 2009
Soup spills into fish documentary
We are all there at end of the fishpier, finally and the good Captain has allotted some time from his busy schedule, sitting relaxed on dock, while his crew works around him, grinning in anticipation of being video'd for national news distribution. The producer begins her low key language dance, working out the psycholinguistics for a good interview.
WHEN IN POPS A VILLAGE SOUP REPORTER
...stepping into the documentary space between the interviewer and her camera shooter, and Capt Fill. "Wait!" she announces, and the camera lowers, pulls back "Me first."
Danny Fill raises an eyebrow at the producer. She shrugs. The reporter demands the Captain's name, inquires as to his business (he tips his head toward the Western Sea, the steel herring seiner rising and falling in the Gulf of Maine swell behind him.) Meanwhile the interviewer, videographer trade glances with the local producer. He clears his throat. The Soupie stops (she is snapping photos of Capt Fill now) and then, recollecting that there ARE other people here, steps back, and Meg the producer restarts to her colloquoy with Danny Fill.
tend to modify the observed, a privilege that is reserved to the documentarians and their subject.
Or should be. Souperwoman stays inside the frame, for all the world as if this were a press conference.
Eventually the interview is over, and as the captain returns to working on his boat, we shift to a lobster smacker, back from transporting lobsters from island fishermen to the mainland. He is interested but declines, politely but firmly, to be interviewed. He does agree to talk off camera and Meg quizzes him about healthcare. The Village Soup reporter again inserts herself into the frame with her own questions and photography. The local producer moves up the pier, considering the next interviewees. They head to the North End Shipyard, where the wooden masts of half a dozen windjammers rake the sky.
Captain Brenda Thomas of the schooner Isaac Evans is nowhere to be found, but the Souper proves useful and finds him the boat's phone #. He calls and reaches her husband, who listens to the proposition of being interviewed. Shortly he walks up through the shipyard. An interview with he, (much Soup insertion, of course). Finally Captain Walker shows, agrees to be interviewed, too, and take camera crew aboard her schooner, clambering across another to reach the Isaac Evans. Only a bit of Soup this time, as the quarters aboard are rather tight for captain and documentary crew AND soup reporter.
Things come to an end. The footage is shot, the words are all in the can. A quick stop to get a release signature from Lobsterman Artie Johnson Local Producer, the the documentary crew a share a round at the Black Bull, and all go their seperate ways. Meg got what she came for. Consumers Union will have its health care story. Village Soup will have its story "the making of a documentary".
And when it duly is published, the local producer reads it and sighs. He's not in the "making of" story at all. A casual reader would think the Souper Reporter had done it all on her ownsome.
He jots her a quick email subject lined with a "Thanks for the coverage of the health care video crew" to fan her ego, but with this message in the body: "...And a hearty middle finger for leaving me entirely out of it."
Childish, but one must observe the proprieties.
Sunday, March 8, 2009
Sears Island: Village Soup stirring the pot lately.
Where's the Press Herald? If you wanta port-hug ladies and gents, go right ahead and spin it that way. Don't just do a big brotherian blackout on the story, for gosh sakes. BDN is on the ball, and so is MPBN Even Maine Biz has done a creditable job informing about Sears Island.
Monday, March 2, 2009
Sears Island lawsuits - PPH holds out against coverage.
But they are out there. Here's an update:
SEARS ISLAND UPDATE: 3/01/09
LAWSUITS FILED AGAINST MDOT SEARS ISLAND DIVISION PLAN
Third lawsuit joins two filed earlier against Sears Island Port/Conservation Easement plan
Three petitions for judicial review opposing the partition of the US east coast's biggest unprotected publicly owned island have been filed before three Maine Superior Courts.
The seek to invalidate the Maine Department of Transportation's recently approved "Joint Use Plan" that grants two thirds of the 950 acre island under a perpetual conservation easement to Maine Coast Heritage Trust, but two of them also want the Court to invalidate Public Law 277 as unconstitutionally giving decisionmaking power over Sears Island to a Legislative committee.
A Searsport man has filed a petition in Maine Superior Court in Belfast asking for MaineDOT's Sears Island Conservation Easement to be set aside. The move follows February 19th filing of a similar petition (pdf) by Rockland, Maine activist Ron Huber in Knox County Courthouse, and a February 20th filing (pdf) by Augusta resident Douglas Watts in Kennebec County Superior Court that also asks for the Sears Island Conservation Easement to be rescinded.
"The fact of three Sears Island cases already pending before courts in three different counties should be a warning to potential port investors: STAY AWAY, unless you have deep legal pockets."
All three Mainers have filed Petitions for Review of Final Agency Action. The petitions challenge the lack of environmental review that the state subjected the plan to, even though it was required to under the Maine Sensible Transportation Policy Act and the Maine Site Location of Development Act".
Two of the plaintiffs, Mr Huber and Mr. McLaughlin, also take issue with the constitutionality of Public Law Chapter 277 "An Act Regarding the Management and Use of Sears Island", which granted the Maine Legislature's Transportation Committee executive branch-type power to approve, disapprove or modify Maine DOT's Joint Use Plan partitioning Sears Island.
Huber and McLaughlin say PL 277 violates the Maine Constitution's distribution of powers section and asks that the Court declare the January vote by the Transportation Committee approving MDOT's division of Sears Island unconstitutional and thus invalid.
The plantiffs also vary in their "standing" assertions. Doug Watts describes himself in his petition as "an avid user of the Penobscot River and its tributaries near Sears Island since 1982." and wrote to the court that the conservation easement signed by MDOt and Maine Coast Heritage Trust "will irrevocably harm his ability to continue using and enjoying the Penobscot River and these tributaries as he has done since 1982."
Huber notes that he hikes the island "and snorkles the island's shallows in communion with the natural residents he was charged in 1992 by God Almighty with stewarding and restoring; in particular the brackish water nurseries and diadromous fish shelter habitats surrounding Sears Island in Searsport Harbor, Long Cove and Stockton Harbor. The final agency action he seeks to be reviewed will irrevocably harm his ability to enjoy, use, steward and restore this area."
McLaughlin explained to the court that he "has been an avid user and protector of the natural resources and wild residents of Sears Island and her surrounding estuarine water complex since 1947. Mr McLaughlin hiked the island and swam in the island's shallows with his grandparents and now enjoys those same activities with his own grandchildren. Mr McLaughlin feels a strong
responsibility to ensure our generation passes on the treasure that is Sears
Island as a gift to future generations. The final agency action he seeks to be
reviewed will irrevocably harm his ability to enjoy, use, steward and restore this area"
All three plaintiffs are asking the Court to "rescind" the Jan. 22, 2009 conservation easement until the MDOT has fully complied with the requirements of the Maine Sensible Transportation Policy Act
Watts played an important role in development and passage of the Maine Sensible Transportation Policy Act late 80s and early 90's.
Huber played a role in fending off Governor Angus King's woodchip port plan in 1996, and Governor Baldacci's LNG port plan in 2005.
There are as-yet-confirmed reports that a fourth Mainer will file a petition for review of Maine DOT's Sears Island plan later this week .
For more information:
Ron Huber 207-691-7485 e: coastwatch@gmail.com
Harlan McLaughlin 207-548-9962 pearlsb4swine@bluestreakme.com
Doug Watts 207-622-1003 e: info@dougwatts.com
###